Trenchless Construction:
Alternative Dispute Resolution

In today’s fast-paced infrastructure environment, trenchless construction has become a go-to method for installing underground utilities without tearing up streets or disrupting communities. But while these techniques reduce surface impact, they can introduce new challenges—particularly when things go wrong beneath the surface. When a directional drill veers off course, a pipe bursting operation damages nearby utilities, or miscommunication leads to costly delays, disputes often follow. Litigation? That’s expensive, slow, and combative. Instead, alternative dispute resolution (ADR) offers a smarter path—one that resolves conflict faster, more affordably, and with less friction. At Discovery Experts, we specialize in helping stakeholders navigate trenchless construction disputes through mediation, arbitration, and expert analysis. With a blend of engineering insight and legal fluency, our team helps clients cut through complexity and reach resolution without dragging their case into court.

Horizontal directional drilling team managing trenchless construction dispute risks on-site

Understanding the Role of Discovery Experts in Trenchless Construction ADR

Trenchless technology has revolutionized how underground infrastructure is installed—whether it’s fiber optic lines snaking through a downtown corridor or a new sewer main tunneling beneath a freeway. But for all its innovation, trenchless construction is still a high-risk endeavor.

Why? Because no matter how much you plan, you can’t always see what’s happening below ground. A misread soil report. An undocumented utility line. Groundwater intrusion. Any one of these can derail a project—and spark a serious dispute between owners, contractors, and engineers.

That’s where ADR comes in. Instead of heading to court, parties can sit down with a neutral expert—someone who understands the technical issues and can help guide the process toward a fair outcome. At Discovery Experts, our role is to deliver exactly that kind of support. We help unravel what happened, why it happened, and what it means for the parties involved.

Think of us as translators between the legal world and the field crews on site. We bring clarity to confusion and help projects move forward—even after trust has broken down.

Specialized Expertise in Trenchless Construction Disputes

Trenchless construction isn’t one-size-fits-all. There are dozens of techniques in use today, each with its own risks and technical requirements. Our team brings hands-on experience across the full spectrum—including:

Horizontal Directional Drilling (HDD):

Pipe Bursting

Jack & Bore (Auger Boring)

Pit Launch Systems and Hydro Augers

But trenchless technology is only part of the picture. Disputes often reflect the utility type and industry regulations involved:

Fiber Optic and Cable TV

Gas and Petroleum

Water, Sewer, and Storm Systems

Because we understand both the engineering method and the industry context, we’re equipped to offer comprehensive support—whether it’s a missed deadline or a multimillion-dollar claim over pipeline misalignment.

The Critical Role of Expert Witnesses in ADR

In trenchless disputes, opinions aren’t enough—you need facts, analysis, and defensible conclusions. That’s where expert witnesses come in.

When you bring Discovery Experts into your ADR process, you’re not just hiring someone to show up and testify. You’re engaging a partner who will:

  • Dig into bore logs, as-built plans, and geotechnical reports

     

  • Reconstruct the sequence of events based on data—not guesswork

     

  • Identify what went wrong, who was responsible, and what the consequences were

     

  • Deliver clear, written reports that hold up in mediation or arbitration

     

  • Explain highly technical issues in language legal teams and arbitrators can understand

     

We’ve provided expert testimony for trenchless disputes involving public agencies, contractors, and utility companies. Whether you need help preparing your case or want someone to serve as a neutral third-party evaluator, we’re ready to step in.

For more on our litigation support, visit our Construction Expert Witness page.

Why Alternative Dispute Resolution Benefits Trenchless Projects

When disputes arise, it’s easy to think, “Let’s take it to court.” But that often makes things worse. Litigation drags on, sours working relationships, and eats into budgets. Worse, it can stall critical infrastructure improvements that communities rely on.

ADR offers a better way. Through mediation, arbitration, or neutral evaluations, parties can reach outcomes that are:

  • Faster: Resolve issues in weeks instead of years.

  • Cost-Effective: Keep legal fees, expert costs, and downtime in check.

  • Confidential: Avoid the public scrutiny that comes with a lawsuit.

  • Collaborative: Encourage ongoing partnerships, especially on long-term or multi-phase projects.

In trenchless construction, ADR isn’t just convenient—it’s often essential. Because the problems are buried (literally), you need someone who can interpret subsurface data, construction logs, and design specs with accuracy. We provide that technical foundation, helping both sides understand the truth and reach agreement.

Discovery Experts’ Qualifications in Trenchless ADR

You can’t fake expertise in trenchless construction. Our team includes civil engineers, trenchless construction professionals, geotechnical consultants, and legal experts—all of whom have real-world experience in projects involving:

  • HDD, auger boring, and pipe bursting

     

  • Utility coordination for fiber, gas, sewer, and petroleum

     

  • Public sector infrastructure planning and dispute documentation

     

  • Subsurface utility engineering (SUE) and geotechnical review

     

We also understand the legal implications of our findings. Our experts know how to write reports that are credible, clear, and admissible—whether we’re presenting in arbitration or testifying in court.

Want to see how our team supports complex utility claims? Check out our Damage Dispute service page.

Our Process for Trenchless Construction Dispute Resolution

Our approach starts with one simple goal: to uncover the facts. Every case is different, but our process generally follows these steps:

Initial Review

Site Investigation

Technical Analysis

Expert Reporting and Testimony

This structured approach keeps things moving forward. Our work doesn’t just support your case—it often helps both sides reach agreement before a hearing is even necessary.

Real-World Results: Case Studies and Industry Trends

Here’s one example: In a recent case, a contractor was accused of damaging a telecom conduit during an HDD installation. The owner claimed improper bore steering; the contractor blamed bad mapping data. We were brought in as a neutral evaluator. After reviewing bore logs, GPS data, and soil reports, we determined that the mapping provided to the contractor was outdated—and the conduit had been installed years later without utility coordination. The result? A mediated settlement that saved both parties hundreds of thousands in litigation costs.

And it’s not an isolated case.

Across the industry, we’re seeing:

  • A surge in trenchless disputes tied to fiber optic rollouts, especially in urban corridors

  • More municipalities opting for ADR to reduce legal exposure and protect budgets

  • Greater need for neutral experts who understand trenchless technology and construction risk

These trends all point to one thing: the need for experienced, technically informed dispute resolution partners.

Trusted by Industry Leaders for Trenchless Dispute Resolution Services

Discovery Experts has worked with public agencies, contractors, and engineering firms to resolve high-stakes trenchless construction conflicts. Our clients trust us because:

  • We speak both the technical and legal languages

  • We work fast and deliver defensible reports

  • We’ve helped resolve disputes involving gas mains, storm drains, fiber optics, and petrochemical pipelines

No matter the scope of your project or the nature of the dispute, we bring clarity, credibility, and calm to even the most contentious situations.

Discovery Experts has provided Construction Case Review services for such firms as:

Southern California Edison Co.
Vast Networks (CVIN)
Quinn Caterpillar (California)
Vermeer Corporation
Salvation Army
City of Oceanside, CA
City of Glendale, CA
City of Santa Monica, CA
City of Inglewood, CA
City of Kansas City, MO
Gulf & Ship Island R/R Co
Tri-Pointe Homes
Rutan & Tucker Law
Ciancio Ciancio Brown Law
Franko Moroney LLC
Grant Genovese & Baratta LLP
Bullivant Houser Bailey PC, Attorneys
Long & Delis Law
Schumann Rosenberg LLP
Bush & Ramirez PLLC

Get Expert Support for Your Trenchless Construction Dispute

Disputes in trenchless construction are often hidden until they cause major damage, delay, or legal conflict. When they do, you need more than just legal advice—you need a team that understands the methods, materials, and machinery that led to the problem in the first place.

At Discovery Experts, that’s exactly what we provide. With decades of combined experience in construction, engineering, and dispute resolution, we offer objective insight and technical clarity that helps move your case toward resolution.